Superficiality in Sag Harbor

Sag Harbor explores superficiality of relationships and the importance of depth. “We were a Cosby family, good on paper,” (Whitehead, 192). This quote opens a horrific chapter about observing and avoiding the abuse that occurs in Benji’s household by his father, onto everyone. This chapter explores that theme of “good on paper” with the haircuts too. Benji’s father always gave them haircuts, and they always looked perfect all padded down (Whitehead, 195). Still, they ended up wild messes, because he insisted on the old fashioned method (scissors), pushed down only for a moment as it’s sculpted for perfection. This in itself is a superficial thing– the haircut– but even more so are the superficial interactions that led to no one pointing out the messy hair until Clive. 

Overshadowing his father’s supposed love for barbequing (and his performance to the neighbors of a good barbequer) are the plates. Those cheap plates that Benji’s mother was supposed to replace with real plates (Whitehead, 226)– a superficial complaint, really, especially when they’d been using them for months. But the nature of abuse is explosive and the reasons for anger are performances– superficial. 

“Shithead,” (Whitehead, 193) That’s what their father called Reggie for a year (‘because’ of Cs). The name had power, and so does the name Ben instead of Benji. Benji seems to be married to this idea of someone seeing past his braces, past his flaws, and loving the real him; “But what of the essential me beneath everything?” (274). He figured if someone really liked him those things wouldn’t matter. Along came Melanie. She remembered him for who he was. She saw him. And she called him Ben (Whitehead, 286). Superficiality is conquered. 


Comments

  1. Annika DMay 18, 2026 at 11:54 AM

    Benji identifying his father's superficiality honestly gives Benji more depth as a character. I agree with the end of the book bringing Benji a truth of who he really is and a level of acceptance from a non-family member, confirming that he is growing into who he wants to be.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Kaylee ZhengMay 18, 2026 at 9:32 PM

    Hi Sophie! Your analysis of Benji’s haircut and the cheap barbecue plates really highlights how deeply performance shapes the image of his “Cosby-perfect” family. I also appreciated your point about the name “Ben” carrying a sense of recognition and authenticity, especially in contrast to the hurt and judgment attached to other names in the novel. Good post!

    ReplyDelete
  3. ShriyaMay 19, 2026 at 10:03 AM

    Hi Sophie, I agree Benji's father did catch me off guard, because Sag Harbor gives these summer time vibes and especially the plates scene with Benji's mom it was supposed to be a fun day and Benji's father had to ruin it. And the first quote you had on how its perfect on paper really nails Benji's family, to everyone on the outside its quite perfect but no one really knows what happens in the inside. And Benji going by Ben at the end of the novel really does show his desire to kind of conform to this perfect outside a bit.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Adrian SchneiderMay 20, 2026 at 10:38 AM

    Hi Sophie! I wrote my blog about a similar thing, and that first line about being a "Cosby family" really sticks out to me. I definitely agree that when dealing with a toxic family situation where somebody 'explodes' at everyone else, the reasons for their anger can be simply an excuse to get mad. Great blog!

    ReplyDelete
  5. mirandaMay 24, 2026 at 3:44 PM

    Hi Sophie! This is a very intresting review on the signifigance of the "cosby" family line. I hadnt thought too much about the importance of the nicknames through this lens and it certainly is fascinating!

    ReplyDelete
  6. MitchellMay 27, 2026 at 11:52 AM

    I'd really like to see Melanie as the one who transcends (or "conquers") superficiality in this novel, but there's so much ambiguity as to her actual connection to Benji's past, her actual ties to the Sag community, and her puzzling absence from all of Benji's memories. It is funny to see how quickly he's willing to revise those memories once they cast him as a "five-year-old mac," but we're still deep in the area of uncertainty. There's no "proof" that Melanie really has this connection to Benji's past, and in the end he's not really sure whether she's his first kiss on THIS night or ten years ago. If he's had his first kiss and has no memory of it, did it really happen? Is Melanie even real? There is a funny kind of irony in the fact that SHE can easily switch to calling him "Ben"--unlike everyone else, she's less used to "Benji." Even though her foundational memories of him were allegedly formed deep in the "Benji-n-Reggie" era. It's all rather suspicious.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Nudity, Girlhood, and the Child Within; How Little Girl becomes Evelyn Nesbit's Inner Child

       The concept of the inner child is one often explored by therapists, modern media, and online life gurus living out of their vans. This very same concept of the inner child; unresolved childhood traumas becoming formative elements of adults’ lives, is explored through Evelyn Nesbit’s relationship with Little Girl. Evelyn Nesbit is the exact character who would need a strong inner child, as she had been exploited from a young age, and continuously exploited since.       On page 42, Evelyn steps out of her car after her chauffeur opens the door for her, and kneels down in front of Little Girl. After a description of the little girl’s appearance, we are given two sentences back to back. “She gazed at Evelyn without curiosity.  She was the most beautiful child Evelyn had ever seen,” (Doctorow 42). This sequence– a description of the girl’s qualities, ending in a short sentence about her not recognizing Evelyn, swiftly followed by Evelyn’s a...
Read more

The Ultimate Performative Male; Lee Oswald as Depicted in “Libra”

Image
The term “Performative male”– a man who performs for women as women’s ideal man to get gratification and often sex– is a term utterly befitting of Lee Oswald’s character in “Libra”. In his case however, instead of performing for physical gratification, he performs for emotional gratification and a sense of superiority that keeps his sly smirk on his face. His audience in his performance is everyone, but he feels superior to those who don’t understand him, and recognized by those who do; other communists.  From the start of the novel, we see a severely dyslexic Lee attempt to read the massive “Das Kapital” and other books to show off his elite communism. This initial performance is met by a non-understanding audience. Nobody gets him. He’s not like other Americans. This lack of understanding/pushback does however bring him a sense of superiority because he is unique in his community. Later, we see him join the marines, with the manual memorized, being a know-it-all. But gratificatio...
Read more

Kindred could not have ended any other way; the power of being unpredictable and inevitable.

Kindred is a novel in which you spend a lot of time wanting to read ahead– finish just another page– to get over the cliffhanger. Nonetheless, there’s an inevitable quality to the novel’s conclusion, and really everything that happens. Of course Rufus didn’t send Dana’s letters to Kevin. Of course Dana had to use her knife. Of course Rufus had to die. Of course Hagar was born. Chekhov’s gun has to go off once introduced; and it always does. The inevitability of this novel’s events are due to foreshadowing. However, thanks to distractions, the readers are kept guessing on what’s to come, and the novel stays unpredictable.  The book ended with a few main conclusions: Dana survived, Hagar was born (of rape no less), Dana had to use her knife, Rufus wanted Dana, and the others were not free. All of these conclusions felt inevitable. For Dana’s knife, it’s almost like Chekhov’s gun in the sense that once it was presented, as well as the dangers that told her she could face it (42-43...
Read more